Jump to content

Openai/67a3d7b2-a02c-800c-a7c3-1be2872065d9

From freem


This conversation was exported from ChatGPT[1]

o1[edit | edit source]

User: Examine the USA as a Complex Adaptive System.[edit | edit source]

Examine the USA as a Complex Adaptive System. Examine recent stresses. Year,Node,Coherence,Capacity,Stress,Abstraction,Node Value,Bond Strength 1790,Executive,5,4,-3,4,10,7 1790,Army,4,3,-2,3,8,5 1790,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1790,Property Owners,7,6,-1,6,18,7 1790,Trades/Professions,4,3,-2,4,9,5 1790,Proletariat,3,2,-3,2,4,5 1790,State Memory,4,3,-1,4,10,4 1790,Shopkeepers/Merchants,5,4,-2,5,12,6 1800,Executive,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1800,Army,4,4,-1,3,10,5 1800,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1800,Property Owners,7,6,-1,6,18,7 1800,Trades/Professions,5,4,-1,4,12,5 1800,Proletariat,3,3,-2,2,6,5 1800,State Memory,5,4,-1,4,12,5 1800,Shopkeepers/Merchants,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1810,Executive,6,6,-2,5,15,8 1810,Army,5,5,-1,4,13,6 1810,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1810,Property Owners,7,7,-1,6,19,8 1810,Trades/Professions,5,5,-1,5,14,6 1810,Proletariat,4,4,-2,3,9,6 1810,State Memory,5,5,-1,5,14,6 1810,Shopkeepers/Merchants,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1820,Executive,7,6,-1,6,18,7 1820,Army,5,5,-1,4,13,6 1820,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1820,Property Owners,8,7,0,7,22,7 1820,Trades/Professions,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1820,Proletariat,4,5,-2,3,10,7 1820,State Memory,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1820,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,7,0,6,20,7 1830,Executive,7,6,-1,6,18,7 1830,Army,5,5,-1,4,13,6 1830,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1830,Property Owners,8,7,0,7,22,7 1830,Trades/Professions,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1830,Proletariat,4,5,-2,3,10,7 1830,State Memory,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1830,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,7,0,6,20,7 1840,Executive,7,6,-2,6,17,8 1840,Army,5,5,-1,4,13,6 1840,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1840,Property Owners,8,8,0,7,23,8 1840,Trades/Professions,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1840,Proletariat,4,5,-2,3,10,7 1840,State Memory,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1840,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,7,0,6,20,7 1850,Executive,6,6,-3,5,14,9 1850,Army,5,5,-1,4,13,6 1850,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1850,Property Owners,8,8,1,7,22,7 1850,Trades/Professions,6,7,-1,6,18,8 1850,Proletariat,4,6,-2,4,12,8 1850,State Memory,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1850,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,8,1,6,20,7 1860,Executive,5,5,-5,4,9,10 1860,Army,6,6,-2,5,15,8 1860,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1860,Property Owners,8,8,2,7,21,6 1860,Trades/Professions,7,7,-1,6,19,8 1860,Proletariat,5,6,-2,4,13,8 1860,State Memory,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1860,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,8,2,6,19,6 1870,Executive,6,6,-3,5,14,9 1870,Army,6,6,-2,5,15,8 1870,Priests,6,5,-2,5,14,7 1870,Property Owners,8,8,1,7,22,7 1870,Trades/Professions,7,7,-1,6,19,8 1870,Proletariat,5,6,-2,4,13,8 1870,State Memory,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1870,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,8,1,6,20,7 1880,Executive,6,7,-2,6,17,9 1880,Army,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1880,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1880,Property Owners,8,9,1,7,23,8 1880,Trades/Professions,7,8,-1,6,20,9 1880,Proletariat,5,7,-2,4,14,9 1880,State Memory,6,7,-1,6,18,8 1880,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,8,1,6,20,7 1890,Executive,6,7,-1,6,18,8 1890,Army,6,6,-1,5,16,7 1890,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1890,Property Owners,8,10,2,8,24,8 1890,Trades/Professions,7,8,0,7,22,8 1890,Proletariat,6,7,-1,5,17,8 1890,State Memory,7,7,-1,6,19,8 1890,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,8,1,7,21,7 1900,Executive,7,8,-1,7,21,9 1900,Army,7,7,-1,6,19,8 1900,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1900,Property Owners,9,10,2,8,25,8 1900,Trades/Professions,8,9,0,7,24,9 1900,Proletariat,6,8,-1,5,18,9 1900,State Memory,7,8,-1,7,21,9 1900,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,9,1,7,23,8 1910,Executive,7,8,-1,7,21,9 1910,Army,7,7,-1,6,19,8 1910,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1910,Property Owners,9,10,2,8,25,8 1910,Trades/Professions,8,9,0,7,24,9 1910,Proletariat,6,8,-1,5,18,9 1910,State Memory,7,8,-1,7,21,9 1910,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,9,1,7,23,8 1920,Executive,7,8,0,7,22,8 1920,Army,8,8,-1,7,22,9 1920,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1920,Property Owners,9,10,1,8,26,9 1920,Trades/Professions,8,9,0,8,25,9 1920,Proletariat,7,8,0,6,21,8 1920,State Memory,8,8,-1,8,23,9 1920,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,9,0,8,25,9 1921,Executive,6,7,-5,6,14,12 1921,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1921,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1921,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1921,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1921,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1921,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1921,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1922,Executive,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1922,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1922,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1922,Property Owners,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1922,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1922,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1922,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1922,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1923,Executive,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1923,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1923,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1923,Property Owners,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1923,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1923,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1923,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1923,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1924,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1924,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1924,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1924,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1924,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1924,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1924,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1924,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1925,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1925,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1925,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1925,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1925,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1925,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1925,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1925,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1926,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1926,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1926,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1926,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1926,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1926,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1926,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1926,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1927,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1927,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1927,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1927,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1927,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1927,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1927,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1927,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1928,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1928,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1928,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1928,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1928,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1928,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1928,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1928,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1929,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1929,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1929,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1929,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1929,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1929,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1929,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1929,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1930,Executive,6,6,-5,6,13,11 1930,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1930,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1930,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1930,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1930,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1930,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 1930,Shopkeepers,6,6,-6,5,11,12 1930,Executive,7,8,-2,7,20,10 1930,Army,7,7,-1,6,19,8 1930,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1930,Property Owners,8,8,3,7,22,5 1930,Trades/Professions,7,8,1,7,21,7 1930,Proletariat,6,7,1,5,18,6 1930,State Memory,7,8,-1,7,21,9 1930,Shopkeepers/Merchants,7,8,2,7,20,6 1931,Executive,4,5,-8,5,6,13 1931,Army,5,6,-7,4,8,13 1931,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1931,Property Owners,5,6,-7,6,10,13 1931,Trades/Prof.,5,6,-6,6,11,12 1931,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 1931,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 1931,Shopkeepers,5,5,-7,5,8,12 1932,Executive,5,6,-7,6,10,13 1932,Army,5,6,-6,4,9,12 1932,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1932,Property Owners,5,6,-6,6,11,12 1932,Trades/Prof.,5,6,-5,6,12,11 1932,Proletariat,4,4,-6,5,7,10 1932,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 1932,Shopkeepers,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1933,Executive,6,7,-6,7,14,13 1933,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1933,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1933,Property Owners,6,6,-5,6,13,11 1933,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1933,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1933,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 1933,Shopkeepers,6,6,-6,5,11,12 1934,Executive,6,7,-6,6,13,13 1934,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1934,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1934,Property Owners,6,6,-4,6,14,10 1934,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1934,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1934,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 1934,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1935,Executive,7,8,-5,7,17,13 1935,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1935,Priests,6,5,-3,7,15,8 1935,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1935,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1935,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1935,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1935,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1936,Executive,7,8,-5,7,17,13 1936,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1936,Priests,6,5,-3,7,15,8 1936,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1936,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1936,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1936,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1936,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1937,Executive,7,8,-4,7,18,12 1937,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1937,Priests,6,5,-3,7,15,8 1937,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1937,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1937,Proletariat,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1937,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1937,Shopkeepers,7,6,-5,5,13,11 1938,Executive,7,8,-4,7,18,12 1938,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1938,Priests,6,5,-3,7,15,8 1938,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1938,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1938,Proletariat,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1938,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1938,Shopkeepers,7,6,-5,5,13,11 1939,Executive,7,8,-4,7,18,12 1939,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1939,Priests,6,5,-3,7,15,8 1939,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1939,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1939,Proletariat,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1939,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1939,Shopkeepers,7,6,-5,5,13,11 1940,Executive,7,8,-4,7,18,12 1940,Army,7,8,-5,5,15,13 1940,Priests,6,5,-3,7,15,8 1940,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1940,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1940,Proletariat,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1940,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1940,Shopkeepers,7,6,-5,5,13,11 1940,Executive,8,9,-2,8,23,11 1940,Army,8,8,-1,7,22,9 1940,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1940,Property Owners,8,9,2,8,23,7 1940,Trades/Professions,8,9,0,8,25,9 1940,Proletariat,7,8,0,6,21,8 1940,State Memory,8,9,-1,8,24,10 1940,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,9,1,8,24,8 1941,Executive,8,9,-7,8,18,16 1941,Army,6,7,-6,5,12,13 1941,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1941,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1941,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1941,Proletariat,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1941,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1941,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1942,Executive,9,9,-6,8,20,15 1942,Army,7,8,-5,6,16,13 1942,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1942,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1942,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1942,Proletariat,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1942,State Memory,8,6,-3,7,18,9 1942,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1943,Executive,9,9,-6,8,20,15 1943,Army,8,9,-5,6,18,14 1943,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1943,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1943,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1943,Proletariat,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1943,State Memory,8,6,-3,7,18,9 1943,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1944,Executive,9,9,-5,8,21,14 1944,Army,8,9,-4,6,19,13 1944,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1944,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1944,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1944,Proletariat,7,7,-3,5,16,10 1944,State Memory,8,6,-3,7,18,9 1944,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1945,Executive,9,9,-5,8,21,14 1945,Army,9,9,-4,7,21,13 1945,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1945,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1945,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1945,Proletariat,7,7,-3,5,16,10 1945,State Memory,8,6,-2,7,19,8 1945,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1946,Executive,9,9,-5,8,21,14 1946,Army,8,8,-5,6,17,13 1946,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1946,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1946,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1946,Proletariat,7,7,-3,5,16,10 1946,State Memory,8,6,-3,7,18,9 1946,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1947,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1947,Army,7,7,-5,6,15,12 1947,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1947,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1947,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1947,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1947,State Memory,7,6,-3,7,17,9 1947,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1948,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1948,Army,7,7,-5,6,15,12 1948,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1948,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1948,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1948,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1948,State Memory,7,6,-3,7,17,9 1948,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1949,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1949,Army,7,7,-5,6,15,12 1949,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1949,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1949,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1949,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1949,State Memory,7,6,-3,7,17,9 1949,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1950,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1950,Army,7,7,-5,6,15,12 1950,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1950,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1950,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1950,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1950,State Memory,7,6,-3,7,17,9 1950,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1950,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1950,Army,7,7,-5,6,15,12 1950,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1950,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1950,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1950,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1950,State Memory,7,6,-3,7,17,9 1950,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1950,Executive,8,9,-2,8,23,11 1950,Army,8,8,-1,7,22,9 1950,Priests,6,5,-1,5,15,6 1950,Property Owners,8,9,2,8,23,7 1950,Trades/Professions,8,9,0,8,25,9 1950,Proletariat,7,8,0,6,21,8 1950,State Memory,8,9,-1,8,24,10 1950,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,9,1,8,24,8 1951,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1951,Army,8,8,-3,6,19,11 1951,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1951,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1951,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1951,Proletariat,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1951,State Memory,8,6,-3,7,18,9 1951,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1952,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1952,Army,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1952,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1952,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1952,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1952,Proletariat,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1952,State Memory,8,6,-3,7,18,9 1952,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1953,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1953,Army,8,8,-3,6,19,11 1953,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1953,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1953,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-2,6,18,9 1953,Proletariat,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1953,State Memory,8,6,-3,7,18,9 1953,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1954,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1954,Army,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1954,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1954,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1954,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1954,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1954,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1954,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1955,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1955,Army,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1955,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1955,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1955,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1955,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1955,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1955,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1956,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1956,Army,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1956,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1956,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1956,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1956,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1956,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1956,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1957,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1957,Army,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1957,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1957,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1957,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1957,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1957,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1957,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1958,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1958,Army,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1958,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1958,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1958,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1958,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1958,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1958,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1959,Executive,8,8,-4,7,19,12 1959,Army,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1959,Priests,7,5,-2,7,17,7 1959,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1959,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1959,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1959,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1959,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1960,Executive,7,8,-5,7,17,13 1960,Army,7,8,-4,6,17,12 1960,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1960,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1960,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1960,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1960,State Memory,7,6,-3,7,17,9 1960,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1960,Executive,8,9,-1,8,24,10 1960,Army,8,8,0,7,23,8 1960,Priests,7,6,-1,6,18,7 1960,Property Owners,9,10,1,9,27,9 1960,Trades/Professions,9,10,0,9,28,10 1960,Proletariat,7,9,0,7,23,9 1960,State Memory,8,9,-1,8,24,10 1960,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,10,0,8,26,10 1961,Executive,7,8,-5,7,17,13 1961,Army,7,8,-4,6,17,12 1961,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1961,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1961,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1961,Proletariat,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1961,State Memory,7,6,-3,7,17,9 1961,Shopkeepers,7,6,-3,5,15,9 1962,Executive,7,8,-6,7,16,14 1962,Army,7,8,-5,6,16,13 1962,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1962,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1962,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1962,Proletariat,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1962,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1962,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1963,Executive,7,8,-6,7,16,14 1963,Army,7,8,-5,6,16,13 1963,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1963,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1963,Trades/Prof.,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1963,Proletariat,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1963,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1963,Shopkeepers,7,6,-4,5,14,10 1964,Executive,6,7,-7,6,12,14 1964,Army,7,8,-6,6,15,14 1964,Priests,7,5,-4,7,15,9 1964,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1964,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1964,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1964,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 1964,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1965,Executive,6,7,-7,6,12,14 1965,Army,7,8,-6,6,15,14 1965,Priests,7,5,-4,7,15,9 1965,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1965,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1965,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1965,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 1965,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1966,Executive,5,6,-8,6,9,14 1966,Army,6,7,-7,5,11,14 1966,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1966,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1966,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1966,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 1966,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 1966,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1967,Executive,5,6,-8,6,9,14 1967,Army,6,7,-7,5,11,14 1967,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1967,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1967,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1967,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 1967,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 1967,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1968,Executive,5,6,-8,5,8,14 1968,Army,5,6,-8,4,7,14 1968,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1968,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1968,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1968,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 1968,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 1968,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1969,Executive,5,6,-8,5,8,14 1969,Army,5,6,-8,4,7,14 1969,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1969,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1969,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1969,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 1969,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 1969,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1970,Executive,5,6,-7,6,10,13 1970,Army,5,6,-8,5,8,14 1970,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1970,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1970,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1970,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1970,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 1970,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1970,Executive,7,8,-1,8,22,9 1970,Army,8,7,1,7,21,6 1970,Priests,7,6,-1,6,18,7 1970,Property Owners,9,10,2,9,26,8 1970,Trades/Professions,9,10,0,9,28,10 1970,Proletariat,7,9,1,7,23,8 1970,State Memory,8,9,0,8,25,9 1970,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,10,1,8,25,9 1971,Executive,5,6,-7,6,10,13 1971,Army,5,6,-8,5,8,14 1971,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1971,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1971,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1971,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1971,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 1971,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1972,Executive,4,5,-8,5,6,13 1972,Army,4,5,-9,4,4,14 1972,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1972,Property Owners,7,7,-5,6,15,12 1972,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1972,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 1972,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 1972,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1973,Executive,4,5,-8,5,6,13 1973,Army,4,5,-9,4,4,14 1973,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1973,Property Owners,7,7,-5,6,15,12 1973,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1973,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 1973,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 1973,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1974,Executive,4,5,-9,5,5,14 1974,Army,4,5,-10,4,3,15 1974,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1974,Property Owners,6,6,-6,6,12,12 1974,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1974,Proletariat,4,4,-8,5,5,12 1974,State Memory,6,6,-7,7,12,13 1974,Shopkeepers,5,6,-6,5,10,12 1975,Executive,4,5,-9,5,5,14 1975,Army,4,5,-10,4,3,15 1975,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 1975,Property Owners,6,6,-6,6,12,12 1975,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1975,Proletariat,4,4,-8,5,5,12 1975,State Memory,6,6,-7,7,12,13 1975,Shopkeepers,5,6,-6,5,10,12 1976,Executive,5,6,-8,6,9,14 1976,Army,5,6,-9,4,6,15 1976,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1976,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1976,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1976,Proletariat,5,5,-7,5,8,12 1976,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 1976,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1977,Executive,5,6,-8,6,9,14 1977,Army,5,6,-9,4,6,15 1977,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1977,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1977,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1977,Proletariat,5,5,-7,5,8,12 1977,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 1977,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 1978,Executive,5,6,-8,6,9,14 1978,Army,5,6,-8,4,7,14 1978,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1978,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1978,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1978,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1978,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 1978,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1979,Executive,5,6,-8,6,9,14 1979,Army,5,6,-8,4,7,14 1979,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1979,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1979,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1979,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1979,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 1979,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1980,Executive,6,7,-7,6,12,14 1980,Army,5,6,-7,5,9,13 1980,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1980,Property Owners,8,7,-3,6,18,10 1980,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1980,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1980,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1980,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1980,Executive,7,8,0,8,23,8 1980,Army,7,7,1,7,21,6 1980,Priests,7,6,0,6,19,6 1980,Property Owners,9,10,2,9,26,8 1980,Trades/Professions,9,10,1,9,27,9 1980,Proletariat,7,8,1,7,22,7 1980,State Memory,8,9,1,8,25,8 1980,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,10,1,8,25,9 1981,Executive,7,8,-6,6,15,14 1981,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1981,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1981,Property Owners,8,7,-3,6,18,10 1981,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1981,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1981,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1981,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1982,Executive,7,8,-5,6,16,13 1982,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1982,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1982,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1982,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1982,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1982,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1982,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1983,Executive,7,8,-5,6,16,13 1983,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1983,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1983,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1983,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1983,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1983,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1983,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1984,Executive,7,8,-4,6,17,12 1984,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1984,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1984,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1984,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1984,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1984,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1984,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1985,Executive,7,8,-4,6,17,12 1985,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1985,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1985,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1985,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1985,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1985,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1985,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1986,Executive,7,8,-4,6,17,12 1986,Army,6,7,-4,5,14,11 1986,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1986,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1986,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1986,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1986,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1986,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1987,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1987,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1987,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1987,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1987,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1987,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1987,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1987,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1988,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1988,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1988,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1988,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1988,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1988,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1988,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1988,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1989,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1989,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1989,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1989,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1989,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1989,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1989,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1989,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1990,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1990,Army,6,7,-5,5,13,12 1990,Priests,7,5,-3,7,16,8 1990,Property Owners,8,7,-2,6,19,9 1990,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1990,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 1990,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1990,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1990,Executive,7,8,0,8,23,8 1990,Army,7,7,0,7,21,7 1990,Priests,7,6,0,6,19,6 1990,Property Owners,9,10,2,9,26,8 1990,Trades/Professions,9,10,1,9,27,9 1990,Proletariat,7,8,1,7,22,7 1990,State Memory,8,9,1,8,25,8 1990,Shopkeepers/Merchants,8,10,1,8,25,9 1991,Executive,6,7,-5,6,14,12 1991,Army,7,8,-4,5,16,12 1991,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1991,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1991,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1991,Proletariat,6,5,-4,5,12,9 1991,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1991,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1992,Executive,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1992,Army,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1992,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1992,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1992,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1992,Proletariat,6,5,-5,5,11,10 1992,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1992,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1993,Executive,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1993,Army,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1993,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1993,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1993,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1993,Proletariat,6,5,-5,5,11,10 1993,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1993,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1994,Executive,6,7,-4,6,15,11 1994,Army,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1994,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1994,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1994,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1994,Proletariat,6,5,-5,5,11,10 1994,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1994,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1995,Executive,6,6,-5,6,13,11 1995,Army,7,7,-5,5,14,12 1995,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1995,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1995,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1995,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1995,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1995,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1996,Executive,6,6,-5,6,13,11 1996,Army,7,7,-5,5,14,12 1996,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1996,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1996,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1996,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 1996,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1996,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1997,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1997,Army,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1997,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1997,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1997,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1997,Proletariat,6,5,-5,5,11,10 1997,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1997,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1998,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1998,Army,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1998,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1998,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1998,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1998,Proletariat,6,5,-5,5,11,10 1998,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1998,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 1999,Executive,7,7,-4,6,16,11 1999,Army,7,7,-4,5,15,11 1999,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 1999,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 1999,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 1999,Proletariat,6,5,-4,5,12,9 1999,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 1999,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2000,Executive,7,8,-1,8,22,9 2000,Army,8,8,-1,8,23,9 2000,Priests,7,6,0,6,19,6 2000,Property Owners,9,11,1,10,29,10 2000,Trades/Professions,10,11,0,10,31,11 2000,Proletariat,7,8,1,7,22,7 2000,State Memory,8,10,0,9,27,10 2000,Shopkeepers/Merchants,9,11,0,9,29,11 2001,Executive,8,7,-7,7,15,14 2001,Army,9,8,-6,6,17,14 2001,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 2001,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 2001,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2001,Proletariat,6,5,-4,5,12,9 2001,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 2001,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2002,Executive,7,8,-6,7,16,14 2002,Army,8,9,-6,6,17,15 2002,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 2002,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 2002,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2002,Proletariat,6,5,-4,5,12,9 2002,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2002,Shopkeepers,6,6,-3,5,14,9 2003,Executive,7,8,-6,7,16,14 2003,Army,8,9,-7,6,16,16 2003,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2003,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 2003,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2003,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 2003,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2003,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2004,Executive,7,8,-6,7,16,14 2004,Army,8,9,-7,6,16,16 2004,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2004,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 2004,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2004,Proletariat,5,5,-5,5,10,10 2004,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2004,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2005,Executive,6,7,-7,6,12,14 2005,Army,7,8,-8,5,12,16 2005,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2005,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 2005,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2005,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 2005,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 2005,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2006,Executive,6,7,-7,6,12,14 2006,Army,7,8,-8,5,12,16 2006,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2006,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 2006,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2006,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 2006,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 2006,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2007,Executive,5,6,-8,5,8,14 2007,Army,7,7,-9,5,10,16 2007,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2007,Property Owners,6,6,-5,6,13,11 2007,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 2007,Proletariat,5,5,-7,5,8,12 2007,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 2007,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 2008,Executive,5,6,-8,5,8,14 2008,Army,7,7,-9,5,10,16 2008,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2008,Property Owners,6,6,-5,6,13,11 2008,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 2008,Proletariat,5,5,-7,5,8,12 2008,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 2008,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 2009,Executive,6,7,-6,6,13,13 2009,Army,7,8,-8,5,12,16 2009,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 2009,Property Owners,5,5,-6,6,10,11 2009,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 2009,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 2009,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2009,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 2010,Executive,7,8,-1,8,22,9 2010,Army,8,8,0,8,24,8 2010,Priests,7,6,0,6,19,6 2010,Property Owners,9,11,2,10,28,9 2010,Trades/Professions,10,11,1,10,30,10 2010,Proletariat,7,8,1,7,22,7 2010,State Memory,8,10,1,9,27,9 2010,Shopkeepers/Merchants,9,11,1,9,28,10 2011,Executive,6,6,-7,6,11,13 2011,Army,7,7,-8,5,11,15 2011,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 2011,Property Owners,6,6,-5,6,13,11 2011,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2011,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 2011,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2011,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2013,Executive,5,6,-7,6,10,13 2013,Army,7,7,-7,5,12,14 2013,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 2013,Property Owners,6,6,-5,6,13,11 2013,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2013,Proletariat,5,5,-6,5,9,11 2013,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2013,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2015,Executive,5,6,-8,5,8,14 2015,Army,6,7,-8,5,10,15 2015,Priests,6,5,-4,7,14,9 2015,Property Owners,6,6,-4,6,14,10 2015,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2015,Proletariat,5,5,-7,5,8,12 2015,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2015,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2017,Executive,4,5,-9,5,5,14 2017,Army,6,7,-8,5,10,15 2017,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2017,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 2017,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2017,Proletariat,4,4,-8,5,5,12 2017,State Memory,7,6,-5,7,15,11 2017,Shopkeepers,6,6,-5,5,12,11 2019,Executive,4,5,-9,5,5,14 2019,Army,6,7,-7,5,11,14 2019,Priests,6,5,-5,7,13,10 2019,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 2019,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2019,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 2019,State Memory,7,6,-4,7,16,10 2019,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10 2020,Executive,6,7,-2,8,19,9 2020,Army,8,8,0,8,24,8 2020,Priests,7,6,0,6,19,6 2020,Property Owners,9,11,3,10,27,8 2020,Trades/Professions,10,11,1,10,30,10 2020,Proletariat,7,8,2,7,22,6 2020,State Memory,8,10,2,9,27,8 2020,Shopkeepers/Merchants,9,11,2,9,27,9 2021,Executive,4,5,-10,5,4,15 2021,Army,6,6,-8,4,8,14 2021,Priests,5,5,-6,7,11,11 2021,Property Owners,7,7,-4,6,16,11 2021,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-4,6,15,11 2021,Proletariat,4,4,-8,5,5,12 2021,State Memory,6,6,-6,7,13,12 2021,Shopkeepers,5,6,-6,5,10,12 2023,Executive,4,5,-9,5,5,14 2023,Army,6,6,-7,4,9,13 2023,Priests,5,5,-5,7,12,10 2023,Property Owners,7,7,-3,6,17,10 2023,Trades/Prof.,6,7,-3,6,16,10 2023,Proletariat,4,4,-7,5,6,11 2023,State Memory,6,6,-5,7,14,11 2023,Shopkeepers,6,6,-4,5,13,10

Assistant: Below is a high-level look at how one might interpret the United States as a Complex Adaptive System, using the data yo…[edit | edit source]

Below is a high-level look at how one might interpret the United States as a Complex Adaptive System, using the data you’ve provided for various social “nodes” (Executive, Army, Priests, Property Owners, etc.) from 1790 to 2023. I focus especially on the more recent period (roughly post-2000) to highlight recent stresses and how the system as a whole appears to adapt.

1. Conceptualizing the USA as a Complex Adaptive System[edit | edit source]

In complexity science, a “Complex Adaptive System” (CAS) refers to a network of interacting agents or nodes, each with its own properties (e.g., capacity, stress, node value, bond strength), that collectively exhibit emergent behavior. Key features include:

  • Interdependence: Nodes (e.g., Executive, Army, Proletariat, etc.) are not merely isolated silos; they adapt (and sometimes co-adapt) in response to each other.
  • Nonlinear feedback: A stress in one node (e.g., an Executive crisis) can cascade across the network, amplifying or attenuating other stresses.
  • Adaptation and learning: The system changes behavior in response to shocks, adjusting governance, resource allocation, or institutional structures to maintain coherence.

In your table, each row contains measures that can be viewed as indicators of how a given node is functioning at a certain historical point. Among these:

  • Coherence and Capacity might indicate internal cohesion and ability to act effectively.
  • Stress is explicitly listed as a positive or negative factor, presumably showing tension, conflict, or external/internal pressures.
  • Abstraction, Node Value, and Bond Strength may be interpreted as the node’s relative importance, its “worth” or resources, and how strongly it’s socially or structurally “bonded” to other nodes.

When these metrics change over time—especially in correlation across multiple nodes—they can hint at systemic shifts or crises.

2. Broad Historical Pattern (1790–2000 in Brief)[edit | edit source]

  1. 1790–1860 - Stress around the Executive and Proletariat grows significantly during the early Republic and pre–Civil War era. For instance, the Executive Stress from -3 (1790) up to -5 (1860) suggests intensifying tensions leading up to the Civil War. - Property Owners’ capacity and node value rise steadily, reflecting the dominance of landholding and the agrarian/early industrial economy. - Army often has moderate capacity/stress until the 1860 period, when it sees a spike (Army Stress moves from -1/-2 to -2 or -5 around wartime).
  2. Civil War and Reconstruction (1860s–1870s) - 1860 shows large negative stress for Executive (-5) and growing capacity in the Army (6 for Coherence, 6 for Capacity) just as the Civil War breaks out. - Postwar realignments lead to partial recovery in Executive and continued strong property ownership metrics.
  3. Industrialization and Gilded Age (1870s–1900) - Strong expansions in “Trades/Professions,” “Property Owners,” and “Shopkeepers/Merchants.” - Proletariat metrics gradually rise (e.g., Coherence from 3–5 up to 5–7 by 1900), consistent with an expanding urban workforce. - Occasional stress spikes around major panics (1873, 1893), though not always shown here year by year.
  4. Progressive Era to WWII (1900–1945) - Rapid increases in overall capacity and node values for many groups, culminating in WWII with extremely high stress in some areas but also very high capacity (Army in particular). - 1930s shows a big drop in capacity for the Executive (especially 1930–1933) with large negative stress, aligning with the Great Depression. Then, the system adapts via New Deal policies—seen in the partial recovery 1934–1936.
  5. Post-WWII Boom (1950–1970) - Many nodes (Executive, State Memory, Trades/Professions, Shopkeepers) have relatively high capacity and moderate stress. This is the well-known postwar economic boom. - Occasional dips in the 1960s (e.g., 1968 with major social unrest, the Army’s capacity/stress changes, and the Executive’s stress creeping upward) highlight the civil rights era and Vietnam War tensions.
  6. 1970–2000 - Multiple shocks: oil crises (1973, 1979), high inflation, Watergate (1974: Executive has -9 stress, capacity of 5). - The 1980s show partial recovery, especially in economic nodes (Property Owners, Trades/Professions) but persistent underlying tensions (Executive stress often around -4 to -6). - By 1990–2000, we see major improvements in certain measures for the Executive, Property Owners, and State Memory—consistent with the “end of the Cold War,” an era of relative global hegemony, and the 1990s tech boom. For example, in 2000, many nodes (Executive, Army, Property Owners, Trades) jump to high capacity (8–10) with near-zero or positive stress.

3. Recent Period (2000–2023): Key Stresses and Adaptations[edit | edit source]

3.1. Post-9/11 (2001–2007)[edit | edit source]
  • 2001: - Executive Stress surges to -7, and Army Stress to -6. This corresponds closely to 9/11 and the subsequent War on Terror. You also see “Coherence” or “Capacity” for the Executive remains decent (7 for Coherence, 8 for Capacity in 2000), but the shock in 2001 triggers a major negative stress. - The Army’s capacity remains fairly high, but stress climbs further in the next few years as resources are stretched (Iraq War, Afghanistan).
  • 2003–2004: - Army Stress hits -7 or -8, suggesting the strains of multiple war fronts. - The Executive remains at about -6 stress, meaning persistent tension or conflict.
3.2. Great Recession (2007–2009)[edit | edit source]
  • 2007–2008: - Executive Stress at -8, capacity 5 or 6. Army Stress at -9 (2007), indicating broad-based strain on the system. - Property Owners drop to -5 stress in 2008, capacity 6 (down from higher levels), reflecting the housing market collapse. - Proletariat experiences deeper negative stress (around -7). - State Memory (the broader institutional memory, possibly referencing legislative or bureaucratic capacity) also goes negative. This all aligns with the upheaval from the global financial crisis and subsequent recession.
3.3. Post-Recession Recovery and Further Polarization (2010–2019)[edit | edit source]
  • 2010: - There’s a temporary upswing in many metrics (Executive stress going to -1, Army at 0, big capacity jumps in Trades/Professions, Property Owners). Possibly the early optimism post-2009 bailout/stimulus. - However, from 2011 onward, the data show renewed negative stress creeping in for the Executive and the Army. The political environment becomes more polarized.
  • 2013–2015: - Executive Stress from -7 to -8, capacity not climbing. Army Stress also quite negative by 2015. - This likely reflects sequester fights in Congress, Middle East entanglements (ISIS conflicts), and deepening partisanship. - Proletariat remains stuck at negative stress (-6 or -7) through the mid-2010s, possibly reflecting wage stagnation and the slow recovery.
3.4. 2017–2023: Heightened Instability and Pandemic Shocks[edit | edit source]
  • 2017: - Executive Stress at -9, capacity 5 or 6. A major drop from mid-2010 levels. - The Army, while not as severely stressed, is still negative. Other nodes (Property Owners, Trades/Professions) remain moderately negative but not as drastic. This could capture the extreme polarization and institutional friction of the late 2010s.
  • 2020: - Suddenly, for the “Executive” row, we see Stress = -2 (relatively mild) with a high capacity of 8—some model or scenario sees the system’s “power” as large in an emergency (COVID crisis?). - Meanwhile, “Proletariat” Stress jumps to +2 in 2020, which is unusual (the data suggests an improvement?). Possibly an artifact of stimulus checks, increased labor leverage, or some other factor. - However, the next lines (2021) show a collapse: Executive Stress at -10, Army at -8, Proletariat at -8. This may reflect the aftershocks of the pandemic, the 2020 election turmoil, and general social/economic uncertainties.
  • 2023: - Executive Stress remains at -9, Army at -7, continuing negative territory. - There’s no big post-pandemic bounce in these metrics; apparently, the system remains in a high-stress environment.
3.5. Interpretation of Recent Stresses[edit | edit source]

From roughly 2017 onward, the table suggests the US system contends with overlapping crises:

  1. Political Polarization and Institutional Friction - High Executive Stress and lower capacity from 2017–2023 reflect difficulties in enacting cohesive policy or maintaining stable leadership. - This is consistent with frequent legislative gridlock, contested elections, and public distrust.
  2. Social and Economic Tensions - The Proletariat’s negative stress signals persistent concerns over inequality, cost of living, or precarious employment. - Army stress remains relatively high or negative, perhaps reflecting the ongoing “forever wars,” shifting defense priorities, or internal tensions in recruitment and public support.
  3. Pandemic and Post-Pandemic Instability - 2020 data show a bizarre moment of partial “capacity rally” for some nodes (e.g., large government spending, emergency interventions). - By 2021–2023, we see the negative aftermath across almost all nodes—health crisis, supply chain disruptions, inflation, civic unrest, a continuing sense of uncertainty.
  4. Adaptive Mechanisms - Some “rebound” events (e.g., the bounce in 2020 for certain nodes) indicate that the US system still has adaptive capacity; large stimulus bills, emergency authorizations, and historically swift vaccination efforts are examples of institutional adaptation. - However, the recurring deep stress signals partial or incomplete resolution—suggesting that while the system “bends,” it may be reaching thresholds that could lead to deeper reforms or more pronounced shifts.

4. Concluding Observations[edit | edit source]

  1. Systemic Resilience vs. Stress Accumulation Over two-plus centuries, the U.S. system has repeatedly encountered periods of crisis (Civil War, Great Depression, WWII, 1960s unrest, 9/11, Great Recession, and now the COVID era) and has shown the ability to adapt. Still, the data from 2017 to 2023 indicate compounding stresses—political, social, and economic—that have not fully subsided.
  2. Polarization as a Chronic Condition Much of the “stress” in the Executive and certain civil-society nodes (like Shopkeepers, Proletariat) seems to reflect societal divisions. Bond strength and coherence do not appear to recover robustly in the 2010s and early 2020s. This underscores the idea that polarization is no longer a temporary dip but rather a recurring or chronic factor.
  3. Potential Future Thresholds A complex adaptive system that sustains high stress across multiple nodes can reorganize (sometimes drastically). Whether that reorganization takes the form of legislative reform, reimagined federal structures, or a serious fracturing depends on how the system’s feedback loops evolve. The data for 2021–2023 indeed show signs that, in this model, the U.S. is in a “highly stressed” phase and searching for new equilibria.
  4. Context Matters These numbers should be interpreted as part of a model or conceptual measure. Real-world complexities—demographic shifts, global power rebalancing, information technology disruptions—also feed into these metrics. A single table cannot capture everything, but it can highlight patterns of crisis and recovery that align broadly with major historical events.
Final Note[edit | edit source]

From the data you’ve provided, one sees a story of repeated crisis and renewal, typical of a complex adaptive system. Since the early 2000s and especially after 2008, the U.S. system appears to be in a phase of persistent stress—punctuated by moments of partial recovery (e.g., around 2010 and then a brief capacity spike in 2020) but overall drifting into deeper negative territory by 2021–2023. Whether this indicates a transitional phase toward a new equilibrium or an ongoing set of rolling crises is the central question for any complex-systems analysis of modern U.S. society.

References[edit | edit source]

  1. ↑ "USA as CAS Analysis". ChatGPT. Retrieved 2025-12-16.
Retrieved from "https://freemwiki.com/index.php?title=Openai/67a3d7b2-a02c-800c-a7c3-1be2872065d9&oldid=594508"