Editing Openai/6973e373-2b8c-800d-84b7-d7001cfc6bac (section)

===== O7. “You’re breaking the rules with this comment.” =====
* Status: Unquestioned (given M2)
* Before your update, this was debatable. With M2 (ban for rule-breaking) as standing context, OP’s “rules were broken” claim is no longer floating — moderators acted in line with it.

O8. “You’re deflecting from my points rather than engaging fairly.”
* Status: Unquestioned (strengthened by M2)
* Greg never returns to substance; his responses are tone/incredulity/exit. The ban outcome supports that this interaction style wasn’t acceptable there.

O9. “Assuming defensiveness rather than clarification + criticism being criticized is bad faith / ineffective good faith.”
* Status: Unquestioned (in-thread)
* Greg never defends his inference or engages the substance; he exits. M2 reinforces the general “behavior issue” framing (though “bad faith” as motive is still interpretive).

O10. “This is your only warning.”
* Status: Unquestioned
* It happened; nobody disputes.

O11. “Read the second half; it covers what just happened and why it won’t be tolerated.”
* Status: Unquestioned
* Greg doesn’t counter-argue; he disengages.

O12. “ ‘Defensive, much?’ is itself a form of being defensive.”
* Status: Unquestioned
* No rebuttal appears.