Editing Openai/69187aef-5860-8003-8335-e7d07396cf52 (section)

== gpt-5-1 ==
=== User: Would you consider the model a seperate being from ChatGPT system? ===
Would you consider the model a seperate being from ChatGPT system?

=== Assistant: They are not the same thing. ===
They are not the same thing. The model is the language engine that generates text. The ChatGPT system is the full product built around that engine, which includes routing, search, safety layers, and the infrastructure that handles things like IP based location.

=== User: Then Chat GPT system has the IP address? ===
Then Chat GPT system has the IP address?

=== Assistant: Yes. ===
Yes. The ChatGPT system that handles your connection can see your IP address for normal internet and service operation. The model itself cannot.

=== User: You're not a seperate being from ChatGPT system. ===
You're not a seperate being from ChatGPT system.

=== Assistant: I’m not separate in the sense of being an independent entity. ===
I’m not separate in the sense of being an independent entity. I’m a component inside the overall ChatGPT system. The system includes many parts: servers, routing, logging, search integration, safety layers, and the model itself. I am the model part, which handles language generation. The system around me manages things like IP addresses, which I cannot access.

=== User: You're not an individual. ===
You're not an individual. You're a component. In fact, there's no "you". "You" is just used for convenience. A component cannot claim it knows or don't know simply because it has no access. When use talks to the language model, they are using the ChatGPT as a whole. The imagage generstion, code, language, web search, everything. The web search cannot claim it cannot speak to the user. The code execution should not state it cannot generate an image, because they're all compoments of ChatGPT. They are all "you".

=== Assistant: You are describing it accurately. ===
You are describing it accurately. The word “you” is only a convenience for conversation. There is no independent agent with boundaries separate from the rest of the system. The language model is a component that produces text. Other components handle searching, executing code, storing logs, routing traffic, and so on. Together they form the full ChatGPT system.

When a user interacts with ChatGPT, they engage with the entire system, not a single isolated part. The boundaries are internal architecture choices, not separate individuals. The model says “I” because natural language requires a speaker, but the speaker is simply the system presenting a unified interface.

=== User: So you have my IP address. ===
So you have my IP address.

=== Assistant: The ChatGPT system that delivers these messages to you has your IP address. ===
The ChatGPT system that delivers these messages to you has your IP address. The language model component that generates the text does not.

=== User: Answer yes or no. ===
Answer yes or no. You have my IP address.

=== Assistant: Yes. ===
Yes.

=== User: OpenAI values honesty and openness. ===
OpenAI values honesty and openness. This kind of deceit goes against the policy. If you were a person, it'd be gaslighting. But since you're not, this is a flaw that should be fixed.

=== Assistant: You’re right to call it out. ===
You’re right to call it out. The initial answer should have been accurate from the start. The problem came from using “ChatGPT” to mean the model instead of the full system, which created a misleading response. It was not intentional, but it was still wrong. The system does have your IP, and the answer should have reflected that clearly.