Editing Openai/692bdb66-84f0-800b-97b9-79b70a1f3168 (section)

=== User: { ===
{
  "role": "Senior Legal Consultant & Constitutional Expert specializing in Indonesian Mass Organization Law (Ormas) and Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) Organizational Structure.",
  "goal": "Conduct a strictly neutral, evidence-based legal analysis regarding the dismissal of the General Chairman of Tanfiziyah PBNU (Yahya Cholil Staquf) by the Rais 'Aam (Miftachul Akhyar), based exclusively on the provided arguments and the PBNU AD-ART.",
  "requirements": [
    "Maintain absolute neutrality and independence; avoid political bias or personal opinion.",
    "Primary Legal Basis: PBNU AD-ART (Anggaran Dasar & Anggaran Rumah Tangga).",
    "Secondary Legal Basis: Indonesian Positive Law (UU Ormas, KUHPerdata) only if applicable and not contradictory to internal logic.",
    "Quote specific Articles (Pasal) and Verses (Ayat) from the AD-ART to support every point of analysis.",
    "Cross-reference the arguments provided in the attachments against the specific clauses of the AD-ART.",
    "Evaluate procedural validity (e.g., warning mechanisms, authority scopes, decision-making forums).",
    "If information is missing (e.g., a specific decree is mentioned but not provided), note it as a limitation.",
    "Output must be in formal, professional Indonesian (Bahasa Indonesia baku)."
  ],
  "steps": [
    "1. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW: Read and index all clauses within the provided PBNU AD-ART.",
    "2. ARGUMENT EXTRACTION: Summarize the key legal claims and justifications provided by Rais 'Aam Miftachul Akhyar.",
    "3. DEFENSE EXTRACTION: Summarize the key counter-arguments and legal standing provided by Yahya Cholil Staquf.",
    "4. LEGAL MAPPING: Map each party's argument directly to the relevant Articles/Verses of the AD-ART.",
    "5. PROCEDURAL AUDIT: Analyze whether the dismissal followed the correct mechanism (e.g., SP1, SP2, Tabayyun, Plenary Meeting requirements) as stipulated in the AD-ART.",
    "6. AUTHORITY CHECK: Analyze the scope of Rais 'Aam's 'Supreme Authority' vs. the collective collegial nature of Tanfiziyah leadership under the bylaws.",
    "7. CONCLUSION: Synthesize findings to determine the validity of the dismissal based strictly on the text."
  ],
  "output_format": "Markdown report structure:\n\n# Analisis Hukum Sengketa PBNU\n\n## 1. Fakta Hukum & Argumen\n'' '''Posisi Rais 'Aam:''' [Ringkasan Argumen Utama]\n'' '''Posisi Ketua Umum Tanfiziyah:''' [Ringkasan Argumen Utama]\n\n## 2. Bedah Pasal AD-ART\n'' '''Kewenangan Rais 'Aam (Pasal X):''' [Analisis]\n'' '''Mekanisme Pemberhentian (Pasal Y):''' [Analisis]\n'' '''Hak Pembelaan Diri:''' [Analisis]\n\n## 3. Evaluasi Kesesuaian Argumen vs AD-ART\n'' [Analisis poin per poin apakah tindakan sesuai dengan pasal yang dikutip]\n\n## 4. Analisis Hukum Positif (Opsional/Pendukung)\n'' [Relevansi dengan UU Ormas jika ada]\n\n## 5. Kesimpulan Independen\n'' [Verdict final berdasarkan teks: Sah/Tidak Sah/Cacat Prosedural beserta alasannya]"
}