Editing Openai/69434f20-ed90-800d-ab60-60312c9de3dd (section)

=== Assistant: Cumulative Update — Quotes Excluded Short Format, Neutral ===
Cumulative Update — Quotes Excluded (Short Format, Neutral)

==== New Original Behavior ====
* Admits a personal mistake (duplicate link) and corrects it explicitly.
* Reaffirms argument without shifting goalposts after correction.
* Continues framing high hypothetical inputs as intentional biasing.

Strengthened Areas
* Error acknowledgment and correction → credibility-positive.
* Maintains consistency after correction (no retroactive change).
* Continues focus on question framing and neutrality.

Weakened Areas
* Still equates any high hypothetical proportion with confirmation bias, which is an overreach.
* Attributes intent (“needs the rate to be high”) without proof.
* Tone remains mocking, which weakens persuasive neutrality.

Behavioral Pattern (Cumulative)
* Method-focused, evidence-conscious.
* Will correct own errors when caught.
* Tends to psychologize opponent intent rather than limiting critique to structure.

Updated Credibility: 58% (+2)
(Increase mainly due to transparent correction and consistency)

==== New Original Behavior ====
* Reasserts that hypothetical proportions are necessary for modeling.
* Does not adjust framing after correction from the other party.
* Continues to reject the confirmation-bias critique without narrowing scope.

Strengthened Areas
* Maintains logically valid position that rates must be assumed to compute outcomes.
* Consistent internal logic.

Weakened Areas
* Still fails to clearly separate exploratory modeling from claims about reality.
* Does not acknowledge opponent’s correction or partial validity.
* Communication remains dismissive rather than clarifying.

Behavioral Pattern (Cumulative)
* Model-driven, assumption-tolerant.
* Resistant to reframing or conceding narrow points.
* Defensiveness persists.

Updated Credibility: 45% (−1)
(Slight drop due to lack of adjustment and acknowledgment)

==== - Loctarjay gains credibility by correcting an error transparently. ====
* Captain Blue loses ground by not adapting after correction.
* Core disagreement remains definition of confirmation bias vs hypothetical modeling, not math itself.

==== - Loctarjay: 58 / 100 ====
* Captain Blue: 45 / 100

Both remain moderate trust at best, with Loctarjay trending upward due to self-correction, and Captain Blue stagnating due to framing rigidity.