Editing Module talk:Yesno (section)

==Testcases and documentation==
<pre>
{| class="wikitable"
|+ Test Cases (via [[Template:Yesno/doc]])
|-
! Module output
! Template output
! Expected
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|yes}}
| {{yesno|yes}}
| yes
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|YeS}}
| {{yesno|YeS}}
| yes
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|Y}}
| {{yesno|Y}}
| yes
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|y}}
| {{yesno|y}}
| yes
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|no}}
| {{yesno|no}}
| ''(blank)''
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|}}
| {{yesno|}}
| ''(blank)''
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno}}
| {{yesno}}
| ''(blank)''
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|¬}}
| {{yesno|¬}}
| ''(blank)''
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher}}
| {{yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher}}
| yes
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|yes|yes=bacon}}
| {{yesno|yes|yes=bacon}}
| bacon
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|no|no=ham}}
| {{yesno|no|no=ham}}
| ham
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|blank= eggs}}
| {{yesno|blank= eggs}}
| 
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|no=ham}}
| {{yesno|no=ham}}
| 
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|blank= eggs|no=ham}}
| {{yesno|blank= eggs|no=ham}}
| 
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|¬|¬=sausage}}
| {{yesno|¬|¬=sausage}}
| sausage
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher|def=cup-of-tea}}
| {{yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher|def=cup-of-tea}}
| cup-of-tea
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher|yes=bacon}}
| {{yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher|yes=bacon}}
| bacon
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher|def=cup-of-tea|yes=bacon}}
| {{yesno|purplemonkeydishwasher|def=cup-of-tea|yes=bacon}}
| cup-of-tea
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|yes|yes=no|no=yes}}
| {{yesno|yes|yes=no|no=yes}}
| no
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno|no|yes=no|no=yes}}
| {{yesno|no|yes=no|no=yes}}
| yes
|-
| {{#invoke:Yesno|yesno| no |no=no}}
| {{yesno| no |no=no}}
| no
|}
</pre>
:<small>Note: Pre tags added to suppress script errors. — '''''[[User:Mr. Stradivarius|<span style="color: #194D00; font-family: Palatino, Times, serif">Mr. Stradivarius</span>]]''''' <sup>[[User talk:Mr. Stradivarius|♪ talk ♪]]</sup> 14:25, 20 September 2013 (UTC)</small>

As you can see, the template does not behave exactly as its documentation claims it does. I was not sure which to regard as authoritative: the ideal or actual implementation. I ultimately went with the former. Removing <code>and not any</code> from the Lua code will make the module behave like exactly like the template.

--[[User:Ori.livneh|Ori.livneh]] ([[User talk:Ori.livneh|talk]]) 10:46, 28 February 2013 (UTC)

:Just needs to handle spaces in the params better. -- [[User:WOSlinker|WOSlinker]] ([[User talk:WOSlinker|talk]]) 11:41, 2 March 2013 (UTC)
::Thanks. Fixed. I moved your test case to the table above. --[[User:Ori.livneh|Ori.livneh]] ([[User talk:Ori.livneh|talk]]) 05:58, 3 March 2013 (UTC)
:::Yesno has ~8M transclusions. No question it should handle the legacy 1:1. Test it. -[[User:DePiep|DePiep]] ([[User talk:DePiep|talk]]) 22:31, 11 March 2013 (UTC)
The documentation is wrong. The "egg" example assumes thet the input value is ''blank''. But in the code examples the input parameter is ''omitted''. Compare: 
* <nowiki>{{yesno|blank= eggs|no=ham}}</nowiki> →  {{yesno|blank= eggs|no=ham}} 
* <nowiki>{{yesno||blank= eggs|no=ham}}</nowiki> →  {{yesno||blank= eggs|no=ham}} 
This is what is actually documented:
* <nowiki>{{yesno|blank= eggs|no=ham|¬=bread}}</nowiki> →  {{yesno|blank= eggs|no=ham|¬=bread}}
:I have changed the documentation. Not the table above. -[[User:DePiep|DePiep]] ([[User talk:DePiep|talk]]) 13:16, 23 March 2013 (UTC)